Article Image

The Weight of Unanswerable Questions

Op-Med is a collection of original essays contributed by Doximity members.

I watched two bees explore the inside of my office. One landed on top of a jar filled with glitter; a delicate pink bow encircled the seam where the lid met the glass. The other climbed clear plastic cups wedged into the corner of the window. I wondered how they entered the room when all the windows were closed. I wondered why they chose this room and whether they would survive. And then, I re-entered the conversation as my friend asked herself out loud, "Why do I want to do the hard stuff?"

Louise is a remarkable, dedicated vascular surgeon and asked this question as she pondered what it would be like to not pursue chemotherapy for her metastatic cancer.

As a critical care pediatrician, I miss the days when friends asked me about benign rashes after starting a new soap, low-grade fevers, and the best suction devices for infant boogers. Or, whether it was OK to have a sip of wine in the first trimester. With age and time, questions have shifted from the basics to questions I can't answer. A friend struggling with infertility asks, "Why me?" Another wonders, "What would you do?" as she considers where to place her chronically ill parents. I feel privileged to be a trusted confidant for friends — and sometimes strangers — as they share life experiences and explore their doubts with me. But still, the weight of unanswerable questions haunts me.

I face mortality with unsettling regularity. It doesn’t become easier with time. Some losses stay with me longer than others, and some conversations find a permanent place in my heart. The conversation with my friend living with metastatic cancer has felt the hardest of all. Before we ended the conversation, we reflected on the importance of having some semblance of control. I could hear Louise smiling through the phone as she confessed, “I got braces so that when I die, I will die with perfect teeth.”

And that’s exactly it. The awareness of mortality is perhaps the most universal aspect of the human experience. Birth is celebrated for what it creates: a new life, a new story filled with possibility. The newborn enters the world blissfully unaware of what lies ahead. Death, by contrast, asks us to live with an awareness of life’s inevitable end and to consider what we will leave behind. Listening to Louise joke about dying with perfect teeth, I felt the tenderness of that contradiction: we know our lives will end, and still we make plans for ourselves. If I could choose, I’d die knowing I’d said everything I wanted to say. But knowing me, I’d be asking for one more draft.

As Louise considers what she wants the rest of her life and her legacy to look like, she wonders why “doing veins,” procedures she describes as relatively boring, albeit undeniably life-changing, doesn't feel fulfilling enough. Her cadence quickens as she describes the most technically challenging and intellectually complex vascular reconstructive surgeries. I remind her that gardening isn’t so different, caring for an intricate network of vascular connections hidden deep beneath the soil to sustain everything on the surface. Laughing, she replied, “But what if I’m just not as good at that?”

After a long pause, Louise admitted, “I don’t want to make the wrong choice.” Whether to pursue chemotherapy for a disease that will ultimately claim her life is not a decision with a right answer. If one path were unequivocally better than the other, her oncologist would not ask her to decide. Now, Louise must navigate questions medicine cannot answer: What is she willing to endure for herself and her family? For what is she hoping? And does quality or quantity hold more weight? No scan, lab value, or treating physician can make those judgments for her.

No decisions were made that day. She had an interior decorator come to the house, drove her son to a friend’s, and went to sleep. There was something striking about the ordinary rhythm of an ordinary day. The bees still buzzed on, wandering around my office, completely unaware of the role they play in creating what blooms long after they’re gone.

Author's note: Louise's name and story are shared with permission.

The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest.
Illustration by Yi-Min Chun

More from Op-Med