Article Image

Death by a Thousand Inboxes

Op-Med is a collection of original essays contributed by Doximity members.

The other day I received an email from my nurse. The tone wasn’t kind. A few days earlier, I had asked about the authorization for a patient’s IV therapy. Her response was simple:

“We already messaged you about this.”

I immediately searched through my email, convinced I had somehow missed it. Nothing.

I wrote back asking her to show me the email. She didn’t. Instead, she informed me that the message had been sent through an Epic Referral message — a feature I didn’t even know existed. When I explained that and politely asked if we could communicate exclusively through email, I received a lengthy explanation describing why that would be impossible. Whether those reasons were valid is almost beside the point. The message was clear: communication would occur through whatever platform the system deemed appropriate, and I was expected to keep up.

At any given moment, a physician may receive information through:

  • Phone calls (office or personal)

  • Text messages

  • Work email

  • Personal email

  • Social media messaging (including Doximity)

  • Epic Secure Chat

  • Epic Referral Messages

  • Epic eConsults

  • Pager

  • Fax

  • Microsoft Teams

  • And perhaps the least utilized communication tool in modern medicine: face-to-face conversation.

None of these systems is inherently bad. Most were created to solve a specific problem. The issue is that every new communication platform arrives with the promise of improving efficiency, yet almost none replace the systems that came before it. Instead, they accumulate.

The result is communication fragmentation.

I think this distinction is important because the problem isn’t simply that physicians receive too many messages. We’ve always received a lot of communication. The problem is that before we can even respond to a message, we first have to remember where it might be. Every communication begins with a search. Was this an email? A Secure Chat? A Referral message? Teams? A text? An eConsult? Before we can process the information itself, we’re forced to spend mental energy simply figuring out where the information lives.

That may sound trivial, but those moments add up. Individually they take only seconds. Repeated dozens or hundreds of times every week, they become another invisible task competing for our attention. It is work that rarely appears on productivity reports because it isn’t direct patient care, documentation, or billing. Yet it consumes cognitive resources all the same. Studies of physician workflow⁠ have demonstrated that physicians spend substantial portions of their workday interacting with EHRs and completing desk work rather than directly interacting with patients.

Every interruption also carries a hidden cost. If I’m reviewing pathology, discussing treatment options with a family, calculating chemotherapy doses, or interpreting imaging, every notification forces me to leave that mental task, switch to something entirely different, and then reconstruct where I left off. The interruption itself may last only a minute. Recovering the original train of thought often takes much longer. We tend to measure communication by the time required to read the message, but we rarely account for the time required to recover from it.

To be fair, many of these communication platforms truly do solve important problems. Secure Chat reduces phone tag. Referral messaging organizes consults. Teams improves collaboration. Email allows asynchronous communication. None of these innovations is inherently flawed. The problem is that healthcare has become very good at adding communication systems and remarkably poor at eliminating older ones. Every new platform carries the expectation that physicians will simply absorb another inbox into their daily workflow.

A physician is no longer expected to monitor an inbox. We are expected to monitor every inbox simultaneously. Each platform has its own notifications, priorities, workflows, and assumptions. Missing information is no longer a matter of failing to communicate — it is often a matter of looking in the wrong place.

This phenomenon contributes directly to cognitive overload. Every additional communication channel requires physicians to remember another location where important information may exist. Human working memory is finite. As the number of communication pathways expands, so does the mental effort required simply to determine whether someone has already contacted you. This type of clerical and electronic burden has been associated with physician dissatisfaction and burnout⁠, and research examining EHR use has similarly demonstrated an association between greater electronic workload and physician stress.

This is more than an inconvenience. It has real implications for patient care. Imagine a pharmacist sending one recommendation through an Epic message, a scheduler communicating through Teams, a nurse using Secure Chat, and another physician replying by email. None of those messages is inappropriate individually. Together they create an environment where critical information can be delayed or overlooked simply because it exists in too many places. The failure isn’t necessarily that someone forgot to communicate. The failure is that the communication ecosystem has become too fragmented for any individual to monitor perfectly. The National Academy of Medicine has specifically emphasized that clinician burnout should be approached as a systems-level problem⁠, rather than simply asking individual clinicians to become more resilient or efficient.

Healthcare often approaches communication from the perspective of individual departments. Referral teams adopt the tools that work best for referrals. Nursing adopts the tools that work best for nursing. Administrators implement platforms that improve scheduling or project management. Each decision makes sense on its own. What is rarely considered is the cumulative burden placed on the physician who is expected to participate in every one of those workflows simultaneously. Every department optimizes its own communication while no one owns the physician’s overall communication experience.

Ironically, one of the most effective communication tools remains the simplest. A brief face-to-face conversation or phone call often resolves in 30 seconds what might otherwise generate a chain of electronic messages spread across multiple platforms. Communication frameworks such as TeamSTEPPS⁠ similarly emphasize the importance of clear, standardized communication practices in healthcare teams. Technology has made communication easier to send, but not necessarily easier to receive.

The solution is unlikely to be another messaging platform. Healthcare does not need a 12th inbox. It needs standardization.

Organizations should establish clear expectations regarding which communication channels are appropriate for which situations and resist creating new pathways unless they replace an existing one. Critical clinical communication should occur in predictable, universally accepted locations. Reducing the number of communication destinations may improve safety just as much as improving the technology itself.

Healthcare has invested enormous resources in ensuring that computers communicate seamlessly with one another. Laboratory systems talk to EHRs. Imaging platforms exchange information effortlessly. Referrals move electronically across healthcare systems.

Perhaps it is time to devote the same attention to how information moves between the people actually caring for patients. Because in modern medicine, the greatest communication challenge may no longer be getting the message across — it may simply be figuring out which inbox it’s hiding in.

The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest.
Image by FGC / Shutterstock

More from Op-Med