Article Image

A Month Is Too Long to Wait for a Life-Altering Test Result

Op-Med is a collection of original essays contributed by Doximity members.

It’s been about nine years since I took my initial board certification exams in emergency medicine and primary care sports medicine (PCSM). I recall correspondence then informed me to expect a wait time of at least four weeks to receive results for these tests.

I also remember similar timeframes being bandied about around the time I took my SAT and ACT. It was the late 1900s then, and I took those tests with #2 pencils.

Then, earlier this year, when weighing my options for recertification in PCSM, I noticed a four-week waiting period for the in-person exam mentioned again.

By the time someone has completed residency or a fellowship, it’s safe to say they are very emotionally, financially, and professionally invested in the whole board certification thing working out.

So, it's rough for a lot of us to go a month without knowing how we did.

Inability to pass an initial board exam could ultimately lead to someone losing their current job, having trouble finding a new job, losing hospital privileges, or being taken off insurance panels.

And, if it is miserable to wear a cast for four weeks to treat a broken bone, then how would one describe waiting the same amount of time after taking a computerized multiple-choice exam, the result of which will determine if their livelihood is going to be threatened?

Well, speaking for myself, after taking my board certification exams, I spent the first week after those tests compiling a list of questions that left enough of an impression on me that they gave me heartburn, and I either celebrated or mourned, as I investigated whether I answered them correctly. It was like playing a nightmarish mental tennis match I could never win. Then, after that, it was a quotidian ritual of assuming the worst, in an attempt to inoculate myself from a potentially colossal disappointment all the way up to Judgement Day.

After taking the National Council Licensure Examination, people can obtain unofficial results 48 hours after their test. And to their credit, the board for family medicine does have a way to get preliminary statuses out seven business days after one of their board certification exams is administered. However, the boards of internal medicine and pediatrics do not, with the American Board of Internal Medicine saying results could take up to three months.

Why do so many doctors often have no choice but to wait several weeks for these exam results, when the implications of not passing could include the inability to pay down six-figure student loan debt, support themselves or their families, or practice the type of medicine they dedicated years of their life to? If more boards gave a more contemporaneous indication of how people did after taking one of their tests, then exam takers could plan their next steps more efficiently.

And it wouldn’t take much information.

If my exam consisted of 200 questions and I got feedback a few days later that I answered 190 correctly, I’d feel confident that I passed. If I saw that I only got 95 correct, then I’d know at that moment that I need to set things in motion to deal with the aftermath of a failed board exam attempt. And if the result is something in the middle, like 70% correct, then I’m confident I could handle that too. And I think most other physicians would feel the same way.

I trust my abilities and those of my colleagues to interpret an imperfect or ambiguous test result, especially one that’s accessible early on in an evolving high-stakes scenario. Many of us, in fact, find ourselves in analogous situations at least a few times every week in the course of delivering patient care. And in a lot of those instances, people’s lives are literally on the line.

Additionally, it would also be considerate and respectful to give doctors who obviously did poorly as much buffer time as possible to do things like:

  • Consider the purchase of a board review course, which often costs thousands of dollars, if it wasn’t done previously.

  • Plan to sign up for an exam retake, which may cost hundreds or thousands of dollars.

  • Or get their emergency fund ready to go live should the worst happen careerwise.

A lot of us have dealt with a potassium of 6.5, a white count of 24,000, a compartment pressure of 50 mm Hg, a critical radiographic finding, or any number of other ominous tidbits of information being dropped in our laps between the hours of 1 a.m. and 4 a.m. at some point in our lives. So, this one potentially scary or ambiguous number is something a lot of us could handle. And if specialty boards refuse to let go of their archaic, closed-book, in-person examinations, I think giving all of us the ability to quickly view unofficial results is the least that they could do.

How long did you wait for your board results? Share in the comments.

The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest.
Illustration by Jennifer Bogartz

More from Op-Med